Religulous
March 5th, 2009Last night, I had the distinct displeasure of watching the movie “Religulous.” It wasn’t my choice… honest. Thankfully, my attention at the time of watching was more focused on the game I was playing than it was on the movie, because I think my head might have exploded had I dedicated my full attention to the movie. Instead, I’m pretty sure I just got dumber while Bill Maher nattered on in the background.
Let me just start by stating this: Religulous was designed, allegedly, to be a faux documentary. It’s directed by Larry Charles, who also directed “Borat.” Allegedly, the goal was not to necessarily directly skewer religions, but instead to ask questions openly to expose the hilarity and ridiculousness of various beliefs, giving the people they were interviewing enough leeway that they would do Bill’s job for him. Billy and Larry searched the globe, apparently trying to find some of the oddest samples of “authorities” and normal believers. Bill would then have a conversation with them, during which he was generally out-matched in intelligence and depth, even by the oddballs he found. Following this, he would reflect on the discussion, relying heavily on the juxtaposition of completely unrelated video footage to accent (or, more often, take the place of) his attempts to point out the folly of the given belief. Apparently, he expected the people who watch this to have such a low IQ that they will magically associate the imagery with his point. Following this, we’d get a shot of him riding in a car, grinning smugly, reflecting on how smart he thinks he is, and reminiscing about his former life as a stand-up comedian, when, judging from the clips he showed, people didn’t think he was funny. Some things don’t change, I guess.
Overall, even were I to approach this film hoping to see religion get skewered, I think I would have been sorely disappointed. Bill Maher showed a true lack of understanding, comprehension, or preparedness for this task. The questions he asked to evoke conversation were not deep, nor did they indicate any understanding of what any given religion believes. Speaking of “any given religion”, that ended up being pretty much just Christianity, and mostly Catholic Christianity at that. Bill spent about as much time talking about Judaism, Islam and Scientology as he did discussing how he liked to masturbate a lot when he was a kid (seriously, he said it proudly). Let’s not even mention all the religions like Kabbalism, Buddhism and others that he failed to even touch on. Clearly it was easier to go after the one religion he knew anything about than it was to do some research and possibly show at least some attempt to live up to the title of the movie.
To culminate his great fact-finding adventure, he claimed that there cannot be a god, because he doesn’t know of any god existing, and, according to him, none of us possess any mental faculties that he does not, so we couldn’t possibly know that there is a God. I couldn’t help but laugh. Such a self-centered, egotistical view of life being used as an argument to prove the lack of an all-powerful deity is humorous. He could apply the same concept to physics and greatly simplify the work of a lot of scientists. I can just imagine… “Well, I’m not aware of the existence of the Higgs Boson particle, and no one has any mental faculties that I lack, so it must not exist. You can just go ahead and shut down the Large Hadron Collider. It’s a waste of your time.”
To be honest, from the way the movie was promoted, I expected more. I thought that my beliefs might be insulted, or that at least hard questions would be asked. Instead, what I got was 101 minutes of Bill Maher being pleased with himself, and attempting to use cheap editing tricks to strengthen his point. Not once in the movie did he even manage to raise a vaguely compelling doubt about the validity of any belief. I’ve had my beliefs questioned way more thoroughly by fellow Christians. He did not even manage to raise a single question that I feel needs direct refuting, and anyone who knows me will realize that’s fairly significant.
Watching “Religulous” left me annoyed and feeling like I had wasted my time. The last time I felt that way after a movie was when I watched “The Blair Witch Project” when my roommates had it on freshman year of college. I expected this going in to the movie, but the reason for the annoyance was not what I expected. Instead of being aggravated by the statements made against my beliefs, I was annoyed by the assumption of an utter lack of intelligence on the part of the viewer, paired with Bill spending the whole film thinking he’s hilarious and being proud of himself.
If you’re looking to challenge your beliefs, or to expand your knowledge of a religion, or even if you’re looking for some good talking points to use in a discussion *against* a given religion, do your own research. Talk to people who hold those beliefs. There are plenty of people out there who know what they believe and would be happy to have a discussion with you. If you’re just looking for a cheap shot / quick laugh at the expense of a religion, you could watch “Religulous”… or you could go to YouTube, save yourself the four bucks, and probably still find better stuff. I know what I’d do.